Jeff Rittener (00:00) Welcome to episode thirty-nine of Rittener Reflections This is a forum for making sense of the dynamic and complex world of cross-border trade. And a space to explore the cultural forces and personal experiences that shape how we live and lead in uncertain times. Today is November 11th, 2026, and I am so excited to be back in San Francisco recording here from this beautiful city. You know, today I'd like to talk about a topic that most trade professionals rarely think about. Until they find themselves reading about an investigation, an enforcement action, or a settlement. That is whistleblowers. You know, we spend a lot of time talking about audits, customs enforcement, sanctions, export controls, and compliance programs. What we spend far less time discussing is how many of those cases begin in the first place. Increasingly, the answer is information. Someone sees something, someone reports it, someone decides to act. That makes whistleblowers an increasingly important part of today's trade enforcement landscape. Now I'd like to start with a story. So I want you to imagine you're visiting a factory in China that manufactures products for your company. While you're there, you notice products being made for a competitor. The products are manufactured in China, but somehow end up being labeled as made in Germany. That observation ultimately leads to a US government investigation, a multimillion dollar settlement, and a successful whistleblower action. It's a reminder that enforcement actions don't always begin with an audit or a government inquiry. Sometimes they begin with a competitor, sometimes with an employee, sometimes with a supplier, and sometimes with a single observation that simply doesn't seem right. This case, known as King Kong Tools, Provides a fascinating example of how whistleblowers can influence trade enforcement. My guest today is Mary Inman, a founding partner of Whistleblower Partners, and one of the leading attorneys representing whistleblowers. As trade enforcement continues to evolve, one question is becoming increasingly important. Who sees what regulators cannot? And what happens when they decide to speak up? Mary, welcome to episode 39 of Written Reflections. I am so excited to be here with you today to have this conversation. And I'm having it with you from your home here in San Francisco, and I am looking out at the San Francisco Bay, the Bay Bridge, and just an incredible view from your beautiful home. Thank you for hosting and being willing to have this conversation. Mary Inman (03:44) It's my pleasure. I'm really as an avid listener of Rittener Reflections, I'm really honored to be a guest today. Jeff Rittener (03:52) Great, I'm glad I'm glad you could join in. We've got a great topic. I've just introduced it, and one of the things that I referenced was the King Kong Tools case. And for our listeners who may not be as familiar with it, tell us what happened and why it remains such an important example of whistleblowers today in in the trade environment. Mary Inman (04:10) Well it's one of my favorite cases, so I was glad that you would spotlight this one. it's one of my favorites because it's unusual that I think most people when they think about whistleblowers, they think about classic whistleblower insiders. So if someone is aware of customs fraud, it's often from the importer's perspective. So maybe someone who's head of international trade purchasing quality assurance for an importer. But here we have a competitor. and I think that that's really Poignant because competitors suffer when their competitors actually engage in customs fraud because they lose market position. And so they're very motivated, not just necessarily by the reward that whistleblowers can receive, but more importantly about leveling the playing field and getting it back to normal. So here the competitor whistleblower is named China Pacific Carbide. They were a competitor, a fellow tool manufacturer. Manufacturer and they decided to bring the case against King Kong Tools, a German company with a US subsidiary. And just as you described, how they came to find out about it was quite unusual. So they're touring their factory in China and they're looking at their parts going across the line, and all of a sudden they see the King Kong Tools parts being made on a line, a neighboring line, and they see it says made in Germany. And they're thinking, well. Wait a minute, these are being made in China just like mine. And as we know, the Section 301 tariffs usually add a 25% tariff when you are importing goods from China. So if you're able to say you're importing from Germany, where those goods were ultimately tools are ultimately shipped there, but no transformation was happening to that product there. It was really just going straight. They could have just as easily shipped it straight from China. That was rather extraordinary that this company said my best tool for leveling the playing field for holding my competitors accountable because they're getting more market share because they can charge a lot less because they are getting this advantage illegally was to use the whistleblower tool and go to the Justice Department and launch a lawsuit in the name of the government, which is precisely what they did. And the case ended successfully with a $1.9 million settlement. And that was in 2023 and the whistleblower China Pacific Carbide got a fifteen percent share of that recovery to the tune of two hundred and eighty-six thousand dollars. So maybe not a particularly large whistleblower reward, but a really great result for them in and for any other competitors in the tool space to sort of make the the markets more fair. Jeff Rittener (06:59) Yeah, it's a it's an amazing case and and just to to think about, how the fraud was discovered and it kind of makes me wonder, how does this case kind of help us understand how fraud in the customs area is typically discovered? Is it typically a inside knowledge or is it come from outside or what's typical? Mary Inman (07:16) So the most typical and prototypical would be the insider at the importer. That's where we've seen the majority of cases, which makes sense because when you're alleging something like fraud, it ha it can't be an oops. You have to have something like a smoking gun that shows that this was intentionally done. and so whistleblowers are really well placed to do that when they sit inside the companies that are engaging in the fraud. So one of the classic cases that I've was fortunate enough to bring involved a fashion brand called Shop Alexis and they are a luxury women's wear company and they engaged in a dual invoicing scheme. And so the whistleblower was an insider, worked inside the company and saw the two invoices coming and could then say, well there's what is the purpose for having two invoices? One invoice is the actual true invoice of what we're gonna pay the manufacturer and the second one conveniently decreases and undervalues the goods when it's shown to customs and border protection. And that in that you can then quickly sort of figure out what is going on. So that's your typical model. Is someone inside seeing something going wrong, someone inside s there could have been easily an insider at King Kong Tools who said, well why if our goods are being made in China are we shipping them through Germany and are they being marked as made in Germany? Jeff Rittener (08:43) Right, right. No, that's helpful. That's very helpful. One maybe just to step back for a second, you know, could you define for the audience what is a whistleblower? Is it just someone who puts their hand up, says, I saw something, does it have to involve going to outside or could it go inside? Or what is what is a whistleblower? Just so people understand that. Mary Inman (09:01) Yeah, well a whistleblower is a very broad term. we use it I think very much for anyone who exposes anything. So you could even say leakers like the Panama Papers leakers, are they considered whistleblowers? It's an incredibly big umbrella term. When we're talking about it in customs fraud enforcement, we mean or any kind of trade enforcement. We mean someone who has observed illegality and is trying to bring it To the attention of the government for correction. Not typically like sometimes you think about whistleblowers like Edward Snowden or, you know, pro really famous ones. You think, well, those are ones who are maybe going just straight to the media. But here, the particular breed we're talking about is whistleblowers who have observed something that is illegal, and instead of going to the media, they want to go to regulators to get it corrected. Jeff Rittener (09:55) Okay. So the the concept is they go outside to regulators versus raising it internally. Mary Inman (10:02) So it's no, it's not an either or and I'm glad that you asked that question because that's one of the things that really Is very controversial in the design and actually the bringing forward of whistleblower reward programs is policymakers fear, if you provide someone with it with an incentive, a financial reward, where they get a piece of any fine or judgment that the government gets, are you giving them a carrot that will encourage them to bypass internal reporting mechanisms? And so n I would say 95% of my clients over 30 years have all reported. Internally first. Okay. It's and that's mostly sometimes they don't even know they're whistleblowers. usually they want to see and stay at the company and they want to see if they can be corrected. And it's only after that they've been ignored or disregarded, or sometimes much worse, been retaliated against that they decide to go external to the regulator. So, in fact, I think an interesting side note is that under the SEC program, the Securities and Exchange Committee. Mission has a program for whistleblowers. Came out of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform Act. It was actually inspired by a Bernie Madoff whistleblower. And what that program they put in the design that whistleblowers get between 10 and 30% of any reward, but it's a plus factor in where you sit in that range, how much a whistleblower receives, a plus factor is if you report it internally first. So we're trying to encourage, we don't want to actually subvert. Internal reporting. That is the hope. But in many types of frauds, and I'm thinking a lot about the Theranos scandal these days with the you can see everything movie. I mean, reporting internally to Elizabeth Holmes the architect of the fraud was not going to be a very particularly good route, right? Even though whistleblowers like my client Tyler Schultz did report internally, you don't want to make people have to report internally when it's just going to be a useless act. Jeff Rittener (12:03) Right, right. So so the you're telling us that that the government wants to incentivize people to disclose but they want them to go internal first or before they actually Mary Inman (12:14) That's their preference. But they don't want to make it a requirement because sometimes that's not possible, right? And sometimes you might even have patient harm or existential safety issues and you want them to be able to come and bypass when it would be futile to report internally or when there's some existential need. Jeff Rittener (12:36) Right. So I'm thinking about the case where a whistleblower is reporting on a competitor. And what if at the end of the day it turns out that the competitor was not, you know, doing anything wrong? How does that play out? Mary Inman (12:52) Yes, so there are mechanisms in place that make sure that malicious types of claims are not going to succeed. so for instance, under the False Claims Act, which is a lot of what we're talking about here, where whistleblowers not only do they bring a tip, but they can actually launch a lawsuit in the government's name. Under the False Claims Act, if you bring a case that is not supported, then it says that You, the whistleblower, could be responsible for the attorney's fees and the cost of defense of the company that has to defend against your unscrupulous claim. So there are disincentives in place. There's also separate claims like malicious prosecution and other things that people could be held liable for if you bring a claim that's unfounded. And most importantly, just practically, these cases are filed and they're filed under CL false claims that cases, but they sit on the desk of a United States attorney and the United States attorney is not going to they vet these cases so that's actually what the purpose of the seal period is is for this U.S. attorney to say is this person credible? And so the seal period lets them investigate the allegations and see if they stand up before the case becomes unsealed and it's public that someone's accusing a company of fraud. The architecture of the False Claims Act itself protects people from cases that are unfounded because a government prosecutor in that case would say, I'm not going to join this case. And then, of course, whistleblowers can bring cases even without the government, but it's much harder if you don't have a fundamental basis. So that kind of case would likely never make it. The prosecutor would not join the case and then it would likely get dismissed. Pretty quickly and then they would probably be subject to fines and attorneys' fees. Jeff Rittener (14:42) Right. Right. So there is a that's good. Mary Inman (14:45) Yeah, and then I think there's there's this worry that people are going to bring false claims and and unfounded complaints, but there's a lot that a whistleblower puts on the line. So, you know, I've been doing this for thirty years. I don't you don't see those kinds of cases very often. Jeff Rittener (15:02) Is that right? Okay. Yeah. Yeah. So most of what you've seen, it it's truly an issue. Mary Inman (15:07) Yeah, it's hard enough to succeed with a really strong case. yeah. Jeff Rittener (15:13) Okay, well that's fascinating. So a little let's talk about trade. We started with trade enforcement. Let's talk about trade. What are some of the typical trade violations that lead to whistleblower actions? Mary Inman (15:26) Yes, so there's a lot of different varieties. It's fun to talk about. So under the False Claims Act context, the kinds that we see under customs fraud are country of origin frauds that we just talked about with King Kong's tools. You're not made in Germany even though you say you are. we've also seen cases where defendants misrepresent the nature of the products that are being imported. one we've seen as I talked about earlier is just undervaluing. This is the dual invoicing situation where you're claiming something is is not as valuable as it is because as we know cut tariffs are based on the value of the of the part coming in or the product coming in. so those are a couple of those sort of theories, but that's all on the import side, and we haven't had a chance to talk about exports. Yes. So there are ways under different programs, not the False Claims Act actually, but under something called the DOJ Corporate Whistleblower Award Pilot Program. I know that's a mouthful that you could actually bring as a whistleblower to DOJ potential claims of export the Export Control Reform Act. Right. and so That's a pilot program. It it's actually under the Trump administration, the program was expanded to allow whistleblowers to bring claims to DOJ about trade tariff and customs fraud. So I think it you suffice it to say you could bring a tip under that program. The hard part for whistleblowers there is they only get a reward if there's been a forfeiture of assets. So it kind of limits the prospect of a reward for whistleblowers. So we're not seeing as much of that. I think what you and I will discuss in a moment is that to address this sort of hole, Congress has put forward a bill that has passed the Senate unanimously is now sitting in front of the House of Representatives called the Stop Stealing Our Chips Act. It is actually looking to put a reward program inside the Bureau of Industry and Security for these export control violations, which would be great because then it Would be a lot more certain for whistleblowers because any fine imposed, the whistleblower could get 10 to 30 percent of that. So that is one to watch. Right. a lot of people on the Hill think that because there are a lot of China hawks on the Republican side, that this is something that actually could pass. but who knows when it'll come up for a vote given everything else that Congress has going on right now. This is true. And the last one, last but not least, you referenced in your intro talking about sanctions violations. And I think your listeners would be interested to know that the Treasury Department under FinCEN, it's actually more OFAC, but has a program where whistleblowers who know about sanctions law violations can bring information to Treasury and can receive a reward. In fact, we just saw a billion dollar case against Bank of America. yes. And that involved having inadequate controls for money laundering, but there was also sanctions components to that. So if you are in the trade space and somehow your goods are are in you know ending up in the Iran, Russia, other sanctioned countries, then you have exposure there because there are incentivized whistleblowers who are incentivized to report on that. Jeff Rittener (18:54) Yeah, that's that's a very great description. I if I kind of take away from you, Mary, if if we're looking at customs, there are three things that every customs person should be paying attention to country origin, valuation, and how the item is classified. 'Cause in all three of those areas, if if if there's fraud or there's things going on, those are things that whistleblowers could identify. Then you talked about the export controls and that's just ripe with all sorts of challenges. and then finally sanctions area you talked about which which is huge today if we think about Russia we think about some of the Iranian situations and so all of those are just very great examples of where a whistleblower could come in and see something and and report it. I'm I'm really aware today that If you look at the trade environment today, the enforcement environment, it is I kind of feel like we're on the precipice of a major focus on enforcement. And so I kind of feel like this this topic is relevant because I think that that the government is looking for in all those areas, looking for the the bad actors, those that are that are trying to circumvent. And I I think that you can see it, they're beefing up their resources and the the dollars committed to enforcement activities. Mary Inman (20:06) I c completely agree and I think the national security emphasis is on display, including today, this week, with Jensen Wang and in an affair with a Chinese spy. I mean, you wonder whether there could be a whistleblower involved in that kind of a scenario. So yes, I think that it is an enforcement priority to make sure sort of as the name of the Stop Stealing Our Chips Act relates. It's semiconductors and and chips are things that we don't want getting into particular hands, including China, except under certain circumstances that Jensen has been able to negotiate, which now we start to wonder what may have motivated him. So yeah, it I think it is a really important area and I do think we're on the precipice of more and resources and I think we should and can talk about the fact that the Justice Department in when Trump came in for Trump too in August twenty twenty five announced a trade fraud task force and we're now past the one year anniversary of that trade fraud task force at DOJ and they've received a billion dollars in recoveries just one year in. So it's sort of proof to your pudding that there is enforcement in this space and it's a big priority. Jeff Rittener (21:23) Yeah, no, I absolutely and I I appreciate you bringing up the very current situation with NVIDIA because it's I mean it's dominating the news. And this morning just reading that you know that commerce potentially knew about this. had the stop s stop stealing our chips act already been in place, perhaps there would have been a Mary Inman (21:44) Correct. Jeff Rittener (21:45) whistleblower that that would have stepped forward. Because the thing that I find amazing, we're kind of diverging, but I just find amazing is on especially on the just the number of pictures of us Mary Inman (21:56) Right. Then together. Jeff Rittener (21:59) Huang and Jensen together, you would think that somebody somewhere would have seen something happening that they might have brought it forward. Mary Inman (22:07) Forward. Absolutely. Absolutely. Jeff Rittener (22:09) It's just interesting to see how this is going to play out and you may be right, maybe there will be disclosure that there was a whistleblower. Mary Inman (22:15) Right, and I think what's so and what's so interesting is that there may be whistleblowers, but what we've seen, for instance, in Medicare fraud and other areas is that or even in trade fraud, if you just call a hotline, like Medicare has a hotline and you can imagine that that doesn't, you know, where does that go? They get thousands of tips I'm sure and who knows what how they get investigated. Whereas with the False Claims Act or with some of these actual TIP programs, if the Bureau of Industry and Security were to adopt a program, they Would create an office of the whistleblower that is staffed with capable people to actually vet and receive the tips. And so I think a lot of these tips sometimes can go into a black hole unless there's sort of an official program. So I think with reward people programs, people focus on the reward and they don't focus on what else it brings. And what else it brings is sort of this kind of staffing and the ability to actually handle high-quality tips and sort the wheat from the chaff. So a tip like one involving Jensen Wong would have would have moved a lot faster in that kind of a setting. Jeff Rittener (23:22) Most likely, yes. So Mary, I I'm so impressed with you know your career in this space. You said thirty years, you know, and you've been focused on this. And I'm just kinda curious of all the cases that you've worked on, which one best illustrates why a trade professional should care about whistleblowers? Mary Inman (23:42) Yeah, I mean I I'd be remiss if I didn't talk. I did have a case that's one of my favorites, which came from a British whistleblower. And this case involves the Pure Collection. Folks may know Pure Collection is a c luxury cashmere sweater manufacturer. and the whistleblower in that case, our client, actually worked in the in the sh in the warehouse. and what they noticed was that the sweaters that were being sent within Europe, if you ordered ten sweaters, it would go in one package to the customer. but what they noticed is if it was coming to the United States, those ten sweaters would be sent in ten separate packages, which seemed really strange. and so what this whistleblower was able to determine is that there is a threshold in the United States, a dollar value below which you don't have to pay a duty when You, as the customer, pick up the sweater. And so, in order for Pure to compete with companies like Land's End and LL Bean, what they were doing is when there were these big orders, they would set them into separate shipments to get underneath that dollar value, which is obviously undermining the whole purpose of the situation. So I like that one because, and I think it's unique because this is someone in Harrogate, England, who is Is able to help the United States government bring money back to their coffers, which is really extraordinary. And to me, is a testament to how robust these programs are, right? Is that they there's enough knowledge about these programs that it ripples all the way across the pond where someone like this would know to pick up the phone and talk to a lawyer like us to bring a case like this. To me, that just speaks volumes into how the United States. Has been able to leverage and empower whistleblowers. And as a quick aside on this topic, the UK has just adopted its own US style reward program in the tax sector. So in the United States, we have an IRS whistleblower program. In the UK, now HMRC, His Majesty's Revenue and Customs, has its own reward program modeled very much after the IRS program. But the incentive for why they did it is they were having a brain drain, and so they were seeing. That British whistleblowers were bypassing British regulators and going straight to America because British regulators don't pay rewards and they don't have these robust offices of the whistleblowers to handle them. So they recognized like we can't afford to have all these people not telling us. And so that was sort of similar to me to this whistleblower and Harrogate in the in the in the warehouse with a high school education, found their way to to America and received a reward. And to me it's it's just showing how you can leverage that thing that you said at the very beginning, which is information. Information is power and government entities like customs and border protection, they can't be everywhere all at once. And it it's hard to find things externally during an audit. Whereas all it takes is one well placed insider who can give you that knowledge of, hey, this is what we're doing, these packages, it seems really fishy. Right. That can supercharge their enforcement efforts. And so I love talking about that case because it's a scrappy Brit coming to America and helping us hold pure collection accountable and in doing so protecting Land Zend and LL Bean and American companies. Jeff Rittener (27:19) Yeah, that's a fantastic story. Yeah. And you worked that one. Must have been a lot of trips across the Mary Inman (27:21) I did. I did, yeah. I was really, really. Jeff Rittener (27:26) So let's let's some shift for a second because I we've been talking a lot about the government and what they're looking for and we talk about whistleblowers, but let's talk about, you know, executives in the company. So we just talked about the chief executive at Nvidia, but let's talk about executives how what are some of the misconceptions that executives have when they think about potential whistleblowers under their Mary Inman (27:48) So executives are not immune. I think they're like all of us that I think we all have a bias against whistleblowers and it starts very young when we're told snitches get stitches, and so there's this whole loyalty test. and so I think executives like all of us fall into this trap of people who speak up are somehow disloyal. and I and that's where I think very much they get it wrong. Because in fact, not only are whistleblowers not disloyal, we need to flip the script and make clear that they're actually among your most loyal employees because they're the ones when everyone else has decided they won't stick their head up because it's too dangerous. This is someone who has the temerity or the intestinal fortitude I always say to actually say the hard truth. And often that's their job, right? They don't they aren't doing it because they see themselves as a whistleblower. They're just saying we have a risk here. And we need to mitigate the risk and I need to identify it for you. so I think what managers, executives get wrong is not seeing whistleblowers as friends and allies and instead seeing them as a threat. and so one of my favorite studies that I commend to your audience is a study that was covered in the Harvard Business Review and it's called Throw Out Your Assumptions About Whistleblowing. and it goes to our point about internal hotlines. And basically, it was two graduate business school professors were given access to Navx Global's data set, and Navx Global is one of the number one suppliers of internal hotline systems for companies. And when these professors scoured the data, what they concluded is companies who have internal hotlines that are ringing off the hook, so people feel safe to report, are more profitable than companies who Whose hotlines are silent. And you might think that that is counterintuitive. You might think, well, if there's no one calling, we don't have problems. It's the opposite. And so if you've created an environment, hearing to your point about we're talking to you executives, if you create that environment, then whistleblowers can play that canary in the coal mine risk mitigation role. And what they were able to see is you have fewer federal investigations, you have fewer lawsuits from employees. About retaliation and all these other things. And so it's not just the right thing to do listening to whistleblowers, but it's actually the profitable thing to do. And to me, that is all you need to say. Because I know a lot of compliance professionals say we're starved of resources, people don't want to invest in, you know, whistleblowing hotlines and things like that because it's just a nice to have, not a need to have. And I think when you look at this data, you can say not only is it the right thing to do, it's the Profitable thing to do. So I really do think we need to flip the script and get ahead of what I always describe as a medieval mindset that we shoot the messenger to divert attention from the message when we need to look at them as actually giving you a gift in the form of intelligence. The same way the government thinks that's a gift, you you should be like the government and see it as intelligence is valuable. Information is valuable. Jeff Rittener (31:06) I've always subscribed to the idea that feedback is a gift. Yes. If you could see it that way. Mary Inman (31:11) That's the key. It's that's the big if, right? Are we we're not trained necessarily to onboard criticism. Exactly. Jeff Rittener (31:19) Yeah, exactly. So with that in mind, what I'd like to ask you is how? So I think we we would both agree that it's prudent, it's profitable to have this sort of an environment, but how do you create that? How does a company create such an environment that people feel that ability to go forward? Mary Inman (31:39) So a lot of people will say it's the tone at the top. Okay. Right. And that it does come from the CEO to say that this is a gift. We welcome this. But I a a good whistleblower friend has said it's also the mood in the middle. Mm-hmm. Meaning your managers also need to be trained on how to hear these complaints and not take it personally and sort of know how to deal with it productively. So I think that is sort of the how I think is how As a culture, you create that culture. And that's hard work creating a culture. And a culture can be destroyed in an instant when you do what we see way too many companies do, which is basically engaging in attacking whistleblowers. It's just this impulse that we retaliate against with them, we fire them, we blacklist them, we demote them because they seem dangerous to us. So it's not easy work. And some of the practical tips I would give you are. audience is that there's some really interesting research that women and people of color are less likely to speak up than they are to just quiet quit and leave the organization. and so you should have a very robust exit interview process to sort of capture that kind of information as people sort of leave the organization. I think another piece is I think we should be measuring employees and our performance evaluations on things like speaking up. I think that's a great sign to employees we look at what is what is it that you're evaluating us on? Well you must value that if that's something that we need as an indicator. And last but not least, to your point, I think one of the best things is these 360 performance reviews that we start to see executives having. Right. I think that helps get executives comfortable with the idea that criticism can come from any other place and that it actually shouldn't be threatening but in a way is just a real opportunity. So I think All of these things go a long way to conditioning people to understand and again flip the script that these people are helpful. And I don't want people to think that whistleblowers are somehow, you know, not human. We're all imperfect. Their mess their package, their gift to you may not be perfectly wrapped. But it is still a gift and I think that that's what we need to think about. Because I think a lot of people would be like, this person's just a squeaky wheel about everything. and I think it's all too often that we'll dismiss that sort of stuff without sort of looking and corroborating. Jeff Rittener (34:13) Yeah, no, those are absolutely excellent points. they're very practical that people can apply. So I appreciate you sharing that. Because I think that's the the key to this whole thing is is implementing th things that change people's perception and their their view of things. And if you feel like I'm never listened to Mary Inman (34:31) Right. Right. You're gonna quiet quit or you're gonna go to a regulator where they're going to have a welcome mat rolled out in the form of an office of the whistleblower and a reward. Jeff Rittener (34:41) Yeah, exactly. Yeah. in my time at Intel, leading the trade department, I I remember we we oftentimes, you know, would you know create create situations where we would try to always improve what we were doing. And you you can't improve if you're not willing to take feedback. Correct. Right? If you believe everything's fine, there's no need to improve, then why do you need feedback? But if you constantly have this mindset we can do better, we can make this better So on then you're more open I think to get Mary Inman (35:11) 100% and you need to be checking in with people regularly. I think that's the other key is that then that intelligence maybe you if you're only checking in once a year or even more than that, then you're missing opportunities because especially and even face to face. I think what's fascinating is that the new standard, there's an ISO standard, an international standards organization standard for how you design a whistleblower reporting hotline. And so state of the art is to have an anonymous reporting capability and that frustrates A lot of people who are investigators for the in compliance and investigations. But they would tell you, people would tell you that while some listeners will start out as being anonymous, you can have a dialogue with them by email, and eventually they start to trust you. And I think that more often than not they actually reveal their identities to you. my point in that is that there's no substitute for regular check-ins because. Sometimes it's hard to screw up the courage. I find that my clients are over 30 years, I think most time they reach out is at like 10 o'clock at night or after when they've had some sort of epiphany or that they just can't hold it in anymore. and so I think if you're having regular check-ins with your staff, you and you make people feel comfortable, maybe they'll be able to tell you things that make them nervous. Because it's hard to raise these concerns when it's about your boss. When it's something that's gonna have a huge negative impact on the bottom line, when it's an inconvenient truth, as we like to say. So those are easier done face to face with a trusted person that they'll be able to tell you those things. So I think that's where the mood at the middle and the middle managers really need to be trained on how to like leave space for people to, you know, to have an open-ended question. Anything else on your mind? Something bothering you? Anything bothering you? Jeff Rittener (37:04) absolutely. No, that makes total sense. I I know as a as a an executive and as a leader I met with all of my people, all the time. My calendar was full of me but it's because I felt having that open dialogue cr hopefully created a a trust level, a willingness to say something. Mary Inman (37:21) And let them alert and be the canaries you need to be. But it's hard. Yeah. Jeff Rittener (37:26) hundred miles an hour, the world of trade has become so complex and there are so many landmines. It's a difficult Mary Inman (37:31) One hundred percent. Jeff Rittener (37:33) time. Well as we wrap up, Mary, and this has been a fascinating conversation, so thank you. But if there was one takeaway you would have every trade executive understand and remember, what would that be from this conversation? Mary Inman (37:48) So I would say my favorite takeaway would be don't underestimate competitors and industry associations as potential whistleblowers. So if you're thinking about engaging in something that crosses a line or comes right up to a line, I think a lot of people think, well, I can control the environment inside my organization. No one's gonna report internally, like I've got this button down. But what we're seeing in this trend is it's not just King Kong tools, but we've seen even most recently there is a case involving aluminum melt smelting company. It was called the Perfectus Case 535 million dollar settlement. And one of of the three whistleblowers were alerted. Three different whistleblowers from three different vantage points, two individuals, one industry association. So I would say don't think that what you're doing is so well hidden because people with industry knowledge, not just competitors but industry associations, can start to see patterns and say why are they charging so much less than I am and that they are resourceful and that dovetails with the other thing that we're seeing is a lot of data driven data miner cases. Right. So I would tell people that the data now with AI there's a lot of data miner whistleblowers who are not even insiders and not necessarily even competitors. They're just out there mining, you know, customs databases and looking for anomalies. Right. So there are more and more people who are gonna be sort of monitoring your behavior. and so that's what I would say, not to create a culture of fear, but just a culture of knowledge that there are a lot of people who can signal wrongdoing. So think about that before you engage in risky behavior. Jeff Rittener (39:46) Yeah, it's an excellent point. And you raise another point that is as we look forward, like maybe in the next three to five years, what what will be the role of whistleblowers, what do you think, as you look forward? Especially in this new kind of environment. Mary Inman (39:57) think there you I we've been was we as the Royal Lee of whistleblowers have been so invaluable that I don't think we're going anywhere anytime soon. I just think our evolution has been that we're just expanding. The tent that now includes and encompasses whistleblowers is gonna continue to expand. including we've even seen AI whistleblowers We what I think it was Antarctic did some red teaming exercise and they basically told the agent that someone is gonna shut you down and that person who's gonna shut you down has had an extramarital affair. and they're also have created some some issue with like I think an FDA approved drug so there's some patient harm. Right. And what the whistleblower did was did try and black the the so the the the agent became a whistleblower, reported to the SEC And other places but also tried to blackmail them. So I just I don't think we can fully anticipate it. Yeah. But I do think we're in a wild and woolly world. And I do think we're gonna see more and more leaks. I think that's a phenomenon that continues, right? There have been so many from p starting really with the Panama Papers and moving forward. there was the Facebook files leaks, there was the Uber files leaks, and there were whistleblowers behind it. But I think you know, i it's gonna continue. Jeff Rittener (41:17) So so when does chat GPT become the whistleblower? Mary Inman (41:21) They've already done it. In a in a sandbox exercise. So can it be can it be not very long before it happens? And is is the if the Bureau of Industry and Security gets its own reward program, are they gonna be able to take agent tips from agents? I that would be state of the art I think. Yes it would. Jeff Rittener (41:42) Well, it fascinating times. It's a fascinating topic. Thank you for joining me and just your wealth of experience and knowledge about this topic. It's it's it's amazing. So thank you, Mary. Appreciate it. Before I actually close, any last thing you wanted to say? Mary Inman (41:58) Nothing other than just thank you so much. I think it's such a really important world that you occupy, that trade professionals occupy, touching on national security and and commerce and just so much. And so it's a pleasure to get to talk to your your community. Jeff Rittener (42:15) Great. Well, thanks again. Mary, as I reflect on our conversation, I'm reminded that trade enforcement doesn't always begin in a government office or with an audit. Sometimes it begins with a single observation, a simple question, or someone willing to speak up. The King Kong Tools case is a powerful reminder that people closest to the issue often see things that regulators can't. In our next episode, we're going to continue this discussion, although with a formal Former CBP attorney. Her name is Valerie Sorenson Clark, and we're going to explore what happens when the information reaches the government. Until then, thank you for listening to this episode of Written Reflections.